A State Evaluation Report Assessed Ramp Metering for Interstate Highways in North Carolina.
Wake County, North Carolina, United States
Ramp metering, deployed by installing traffic signals on the on-ramp of a freeway, is a freeway active traffic management (ATM) strategy that is often used to control the frequency of traffic onto the mainline, allowing efficient use of existing freeway capacity. This study examined the post-installation impacts of four on‐ramp signals on the westbound lanes of I‐540 in Wake County, North Carolina, using before‐and‐after traffic data. Analyses were conducted using available data from September 2017 (pre‐on‐ramp signals) and October 1, 2017 – September 30, 2018 (post‐on‐ramp signals). All changes to on‐ramp signal operations, outages, and other variables which may influence regular traffic operations in the first two to three months of operation were documented. A benefit and cost analysis were conducted to forecast the net savings over 10 years. This study also provided tools for North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) to calibrate North Carolina’s on‐ramp signal evaluation framework and planning models to forecast and evaluate on‐ramp signal outcomes into the future.
Capital and programing costs were based on engineering firm estimates. Future projections were discounted with a three percent discount rate. Maintenance costs included the annual and incremental operations and upkeep costs needed to keep a facility operational and the cost of revising an intersection at the end of its anticipated service life. It is not expected that the facility will need to be replaced until after 10 years. Year 2017 is used as the baseline year. The capital cost, programing and operational investments for the ramp metering systems with signals installed on four ramps are shown below.
Table 1: Total Capital, Programming, and Operational Investments
Cost |
Installation Year 2017 |
Total Projected for Years 2018 – 2027* |
Installation (four On-Ramp Signals) |
$830,170 |
N/A |
One-time Programming |
$405,00 |
N/A |
Operations and Maintenance |
N/A |
$63,900 |
NCDOT Staff Support |
N/A |
$356,490 |
Facility Replacement |
N/A |
$0 |
Total Cost for 2017-2027 |
|
$1,655,560 |
*Projections are discounted into the future
The capital cost breakdown for individual ramp metering site is shown below:
Table 2: Individual On‐Ramp Signal Capital Costs
Location |
Ramp Metering Configuration |
Roadway Improvement |
Capital Cost |
Site 1 |
Two-lane |
Extended two-lane ramp 130 ft with 720 ft merge taper |
$238,240 |
Site 2 |
Two-lane |
Extended two-lane ramp 130 ft with 720 ft merge taper |
$214,364 |
Site 3 |
Two-lane |
None |
$135,632 |
Site 4 |
Two-lane |
Extended two-lane ramp 130 ft with 720 ft merge taper |
$241,934 |
The long‐term costs associated with the staff required to support the operations of the I‐540 WB on‐ramp signals are shown below.
Table 3: Staffing Costs for On-Ramp Signal Operations
Staff Support Cost
|
Weekly Compensation |
Annual Compensation |
Total Projected for Years 2018 – 27* |
Traffic Management Center (TMC) Floor Operator |
$636 |
$32,197 |
$274,645 |
TMC Engineer |
$190 |
$9,595 |
$81,845 |
Total |
$826 |
$41,792 |
$356,490 |
*Projections are discounted into the future
Planning Level Evaluation of the Effects of Ramp Metering on North Carolina Freeways Final Report
See summary