Supplement Traditional Methods with Third-party Passive Data Product for Faster, Accurate, Real-Time or Asynchronous Data Collection.

Report Reviews Strengths and Weaknesses of Bluetooth, Global Positioning System, and Mobile Device Data Used To Support ITS Applications.

Date Posted
06/22/2021
Identifier
2021-L01034

A Synthesis of Passive Third-Party Datasets Used for Transportation Planning

Summary Information

This study presents an extensive review of academic and professional research examining third-party data products available to transportation agencies. In particular, the study focuses on work conducted with three passive data collection technologies (as opposed to traditional manual counts): Bluetooth receivers, Global Positioning System (GPS) devices, and mobile device data (MDD) obtained through cellular networks and location-based services embedded in smartphone applications. Application areas for Bluetooth include travel time studies, cordon studies, and path analysis. For GPS technology, the work reviewed is from application areas that include network construction, travel time studies, Origin-Destination (OD) analysis, and volume estimations. MDD application areas considered in this study include OD studies, trip attractions, volume estimations, and mode differentiation. The review summarizes success or failure of the attempted applications for each technology. The review also contains a summary of the underlying technologies, including inferred and known sources of bias or incompleteness.

This study led to the following lessons learned regarding each of the three technologies reviewed:

  • In general, Bluetooth excels in projects of a temporary nature such as construction corridor planning, as well as targeted cordon studies that focus on the entry and exit of individuals within a selected perimeter. 
  • Bluetooth can be permanently installed and is often used for real-time applications such as travel-time prediction on highways. 
  • Bluetooth falls short in its ability to obtain the true OD of individual trips and is not the best technology for travel mode differentiation.
  • GPS technology is highly accurate and precise, and therefore excels in studies that require detailed traces, such as network construction, travel-time and OD studies. 
  • GPS often has lower penetration rates and is prone to sample bias because of its strong fleet vehicle representation. Therefore, the technology may be unable to identify wider travel behavior information.
  • The widespread proliferation of MDD (e.g., location-based services (LBS)) promise a wider and less-biased view of population travel patterns, though the aggregation of data from multiple sources and the coarse temporal resolution of these data limits the precision of studies conducted at small scales.
  • LBS is valuable as a supplement source. It is effective for traffic demand models and vehicle miles traveled (VMT) estimation and has an advantage in underground and indoor settings because Wi-Fi does not require line-of-sight like GPS technology does.

This study led to the following lessons learned regarding the operating agencies:

  • Entirely replacing legacy data collection methods is not likely to result in the best outcomes. Rather, passive data products can be most useful to agencies that use them as a supplement to existing and ongoing data collection efforts.
  • Develop consistent data validation routines to identify the inherent accuracy of purchased data products, and regularly evaluate new data purchases.
  • Consider using permanent Bluetooth receivers to measure travel times between points on key corridors, especially for places where GPS and cellular reception might be unreliable, such as in canyons.
  • Do not rely on permanent or temporary Bluetooth receivers to analyze trip origins, destinations, routes, or volumes outside of well-defined cordon studies or institutional settings.
  • Consider using GPS data to develop a more complete picture of freight movements in and through the state.
  • Develop an integrated transportation planning approach that leverage the relative strengths of household travel surveys as well as third-party OD data derived from location-based services.
  • Avoid relying on a single vendor or data source for any of its analyses, rather developing processes that make use of multiple data inputs.
System Engineering Elements

Keywords Taxonomy: