Initial cost estimate for an anti-icing system on I-90 near Vantage, Washington was $559,500.
Made Public Date
12/29/2003

51

Vantage
Washington
United States
Identifier
2003-00053
TwitterLinkedInFacebook

Summary Information

To address weather-related accidents on I-90 near Vantage, Washington, the Washington State DOT (WSDOT) assessed the benefits and costs of deploying an automated anti-icing system to prevent the formation of pavement frost and black ice and to reduce the impact of freezing rain. Based on accident history over a 3-year period for the I-90/SR 26 Interchange area, poor road surface conditions contributed to 42 percent of total accidents and 70 percent of winter accidents. The high-accident corridor includes a 955-foot radius horizontal curve and a vertical alignment transition from three to five percent within the limits of the curve.

The proposed installation consists of a liquid chemical storage tank, a pump, a dispensing system with spray nozzles, an environmental sensing station (ESS), a computerized control system, and a closed circuit television (CCTV) camera for remote viewing. The initial cost estimate was $599,500 (1999). The control system monitors weather and road condition data from the ESS, and automatically activates the dispensing system when predetermined conditions exist. The system also alerts dispatchers and the maintenance supervisor when the anti-icing system is activated. Annual O&M costs were estimated at $32,800 (1999). Costs data used by WSDOT for the analysis are excerpted from the source report and presented below.

The present worth of benefits, present worth of costs, and benefit-to-cost ratio are calculated using the WSDOT Benefit/Cost Worksheet for Collision Reduction. The analysis yielded a benefit-to-cost ratio of 2.36 indicating the viability of the proposed solution.

 

CAPITAL
COST
Automatic Anti-Icing System (Control system, storage tank, pump, distribution lines, nozzles, and training)
$450,000
Roadway Weather Information System (CPU, instrumentation, tower, and training)
$50,000
Washington State Sales Tax (8%)
$40,000
Power and Communications hookup
$5,000
Design and Construction Engineering (10%)
$54,500
TOTAL
$599,500
ANNUAL O&M
COST
Materials
$28,000
Power and Communications
$400
System Maintenance
$1,500
Weather Forecast
$1,000
Training
$1,900
TOTAL
$32,800

A Benefit/Cost Analysis of Intelligent Transportation System Applications for Winter Maintenance

A Benefit/Cost Analysis of Intelligent Transportation System Applications for Winter Maintenance
Publication Sort Date
01/07/2001
Author
Stowe, Robert
Publisher
Paper presented at the 80th Annual Transportation Research Board Meeting. Washington, District of Columbia

(Our website has many links to other organizations. While we offer these electronic linkages for your convenience in accessing transportation-related information, please be aware that when you exit our website, the privacy and accessibility policies stated on our website may not be the same as that on other websites.)

System Cost

Initial cost estimate: $599,500 (1999). Annual O&M costs estimate: $32,800 (1999).