From a Colorado DOT comparison of two adaptive signal control system deployments
The Colorado Department of Transportation (CDOT) implemented two separate adaptive signal control systems, one in Region 2 and another in Region 4. This study was done as a comparison between two different technologies deployed in two different environments. In Region 2, the City of Greeley, in conjunction with CDOT installed InSync adaptive signals at 11 10th Street (US 34 Business) intersections. In Region 4, QuicTrac adaptive signals were installed at 8 intersections along US 24 in Woodland Park. These upgrades were made to meet the goals of the FHWA "Every Day Counts" initiative.
With 8 adaptive signal controlled intersections, the cost of deploying active signal control on the US 24 Corridor was $176,300 ($22,000 per intersection) to construct, including minimal updates to existing infrastructure that were necessary to install the QuicTrac system. CDOT estimates that the additional upgrades that were undertaken in order to install this system cost almost $14,000. They estimate the "minimal project" cost for the "plug and play" installation of the QuicTrac system for 8 intersections to be $162,400 ($20,300 per intersection).
Necessary upgrades required for installation included local controller firmware at each intersection, QuicNet software and central operating system, and microwave vehicle presence sensors/detectors at each approach,
Adaptive Signal Timing Comparison between the InSync and QuicTrac Adaptive Signal Systems Installed in Colorado
(Our website has many links to other organizations. While we offer these electronic linkages for your convenience in accessing transportation-related information, please be aware that when you exit our website, the privacy and accessibility policies stated on our website may not be the same as that on other websites.)
Total Implementation Cost, with upgrades: $176,300; $22,000 per intersection Estimated implementation cost without upgrades: $162,400; $20,300 per intersection