Virtual-DMS systems that disseminate roadside information using RSUs cost roughly 80 percent less than traditional DMS systems.

An evaluation of connected vehicle technology for ITS deployments.

Made Public Date
02/25/2019

324

Chantilly
Virginia
United States
Identifier
2019-00416
TwitterLinkedInFacebook

Summary Information

This report compared the costs of implementing two alternative designs for traveler information systems. The cost to implement and operate a network of traditional roadside dynamic message signs (DMSs) was compared to the cost to implement and operate an in-vehicle messaging system (virtual-DMS) supported by traveler information broadcast on a Connected Vehicle (CV) network in the same area.

The cost comparison evaluated at a high level the capital costs to deploy traditional and virtual DMS systems along a two mile section of I-66 in Northern Virginia where Route 28 and I-66 meet. The traditional DMS system included two DMSs for each side of the freeway, related supporting structures and controllers, and a half-mile of fiber-optic communication link. The virtual-DMS system consisted of two roadside units (RSU) one for each side of the freeway, and backhaul communication infrastructure at each installation site.

The table below excerpted from the source report shows a comparison of capital costs for traditional DMS versus virtual-DMS at one location covering both directions of travel on an interstate highway.
 

Traditional DMS Item
Traditional DMS Total Average Cost
CV-Based Virtual-DMS Item
CV-Based Virtual-DMS Total Maximum Cost
DMS (2)
$217,000
RSU (2)
$42,400
Support Structures (2)
$231,400
-
-
Communications and Power (0.5 mile)
$67,500
Backhaul Comm (2)
$80,000
Controller and Other (2)
$43,800
-
-
Total
$559,700
$122,400


The virtual-DMS system was estimated to have fewer asset requirements and labor costs compared to the traditional DMS system that requires large mounting structures. The virtual-DMS system, however, would require compatible CV-equipped vehicles, transferring some of the cost to the traveling public. This cost, however, could be offset somewhat through governmental incentive programs designed to implement newer less expensive solutions as older legacy systems are retired.

Effects on Intelligent Transportation Systems Planning and Deployment in a Connected Vehicle Environment

Effects on Intelligent Transportation Systems Planning and Deployment in a Connected Vehicle Environment
Publication Sort Date
07/01/2018
Author
Krechmer, D., et.al.
Publisher
U.S. DOT Federal Highway Administration

(Our website has many links to other organizations. While we offer these electronic linkages for your convenience in accessing transportation-related information, please be aware that when you exit our website, the privacy and accessibility policies stated on our website may not be the same as that on other websites.)

System Cost

See summary