Field Test of Heavy Vehicle Forward Collision Warnings on a Virgina Smart Road Testbed Led to a 38 Percent Quicker Pedal Release and a 23 Percent Quicker Brake Release Than Without Alerts.

A Controlled Test-Track Study Evaluated the Responses of 59 Commercial Truck Drivers to Heavy-Vehicle Collision Warnings.

Date Posted
10/26/2026
Identifier
2026-b02071

Evaluation of Heavy-Vehicle Collision Warning Interfaces – Follow-On Testing

Summary Information

Collisions involving heavy trucks pose serious safety risks because the stopping distances and driver-response requirements of large commercial vehicles differ substantially from those of passenger vehicles. To help mitigate these risks, forward collision warning (FCW) systems have been developed to alert drivers to imminent collisions. The study conducted a follow-on human-performance experiment to evaluate the effectiveness of heavy-vehicle crash warning interfaces (HV-CWIs), with particular emphasis on nighttime performance and the effects of delaying the visual component of an alert. The study focused on the auditory and visual components of an FCW system designed to warn truck drivers of an impending collision. Evaluation data were collected from 59 commercial driver’s license (CDL) holders, each assigned to one of six experimental conditions and operating an instrumented Class 8 truck. Driver reaction time was measured based on accelerator release and brake application. Testing was conducted on the Virginia Smart Road, an approximately 3.5-kilometer long (2.2-miles), two-lane closed test facility in Blacksburg, Virginia.

METHODOLOGY

The study evaluated six conditions: daytime and nighttime FCW alerts with no delay or a one-second visual delay, plus baseline conditions without alerts. Participants completed six test-track trials, with an unexpected rear-end conflict in the final trial while performing an eyes-off-road task. The lead vehicle braked at 0.60g, triggering the FCW at a three-second time-to-collision threshold with an 87 dB auditory tone and red visual alert. Data on FCW activation, accelerator release, and brake application were recorded using an onboard data-acquisition system. Effectiveness was measured by driver reaction time and first response to the alert. Reaction time included time from FCW activation to accelerator release (RT1) and brake application (RT2). First response was classified as looking at the roadway, looking at the visual alert, or releasing the accelerator.

FINDINGS

  • FCW reduced the mean accelerator-release time from 0.87 seconds without an alert to 0.54 seconds with an alert (38 percent).
  • FCW reduced the mean brake-response time from 1.47 seconds without an alert to 1.13 seconds with an alert (23 percent).
  • Participant feedback generally supported the warning design: 76 percent considered the visual component necessary, 88 percent considered red an appropriate warning color, 88 percent approved of the warning loudness, and 82 percent approved of its duration.
  • Driver response times did not differ significantly between daytime and nighttime warning conditions. Delaying the visual warning by one second increased the proportion of drivers whose first response was to look toward the forward roadway from 79 percent during the day and 80 percent at night to 100 percent with the delay, but it did not significantly affect accelerator-release or brake-response times.
Results Type