Lesson

Facilitate integration of CVISN by establishing cooperative relationship among stakeholders and promoting incentives to improve mobile communications and enhance enforcement.

Nationwide experience of CVISN Managers


28 February 2007
United States


Background (Show)

Lesson Learned

To collect qualitative information on lessons learned during the CVISN self-evaluation process, evaluation templates were made available to CVISN managers. Participants provided plain-language responses to specific questions regarding technical challenges, institutional issues, and recommendations. Researchers reviewed the responses, identified common themes, and summarized the results.

A key question (Q42) asked in the survey was: "Looking back, what are the most important steps you would have taken (or avoided taking) if you had known at the beginning what you know now about deploying CVISN technologies." The lessons below were derived from summary data and responses received from 23 states.
  • Maintain continuity among personnel, vendors, and consultants throughout the deployment process. When planning, implementing, and integrating CVISN technologies, emphasize the importance of establishing clear communications and cooperative relationships among all parties involved. Be certain that the state has a clear understanding of federal goals and objectives. Use the National ITS Architecture for the basis of the CVISN design and supplement that with standards defined by the CVISN program.
  • Allow sufficient time for deployment. Differing agency priorities can cause schedule delays. Understand the status of the existing standards at the time of development. Without standards, the development effort could be exposed to changes that will cause delays.
  • Request adequate funding. Lack of sufficient funding and difficulties in maintaining support for CVISN programs were frequently cited as a challenge, both in terms of budgetary and matching-fund limits, and in terms of retaining sufficient, dedicated, trained staff, especially in the information technology area.
The survey findings suggest that CVISN technologies offer great potential for increased efficiency; however, the system is underutilized and only about 20 percent of trucks are equipped. To encourage further development, the following lessons were offered:
  • Create a federal rule that standardizes the placement and format of apportioned plates, and facilitate delivery of information to enforcement officers. Several states identified a disconnect between the need for national standards and the need to accommodate individual differences among the states. Several states indicated that the federal government has provided basic direction, but each state in some respects has chosen to go its own way.
  • Provide a federal subsidy for operating funds to enhance enforcement functions. Note that the larger, lower-risk, safer carriers can take early advantage of CVISN productivity and efficiency benefits, however, the larger population of smaller, higher-risk carriers with limited economies-of-scale may be more difficult to engage without providing them with incentives to improve participation and compliance.
  • Provide federal investment or incentives to improve mobile communications, reduce associated costs, and increase coverage. Mobile communications are currently a key limiting factor in information exchange/ information access.
Overall, the survey group indicated that CVISN has potential to offer tangible benefits in terms of safety, efficiency, and productivity for both roadside (electronic screening and safety information exchange) and administrative (credentialing) operations for commercial vehicles. States may require long-term funding commitments to complete CVISN. When asked to envision their best-case outcome for CVISN deployment in the future, states indicated that full functionality and interoperability were key goals.


Lesson Comments

No comments posted to date

Comment on this Lesson

To comment on this lesson, fill in the information below and click on submit. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field. Your name and email address, if provided, will not be posted, but are to contact you, if needed to clarify your comments.



Source

Description of Benefits and Lessons Learned from State Self-Evaluations of Commercial Vehicle Information Systems and Networks (CVISN) Deployments (October 2003 to August 2006)

Author: Battelle

Published By: U.S. DOT Federal Highway Administration

Prepared by Battelle for the U.S. DOT Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration

Source Date: 28 February 2007

EDL Number: 14459

URL: http://ntl.bts.gov/lib/31000/31000/31010/14459.htm

Lesson Contacts

Lesson Analyst:

Mike Mercer
Noblis
202-863-3646


Rating

Average User Rating

0 ( ratings)

Rate this Lesson

(click stars to rate)



Notes

Lesson of the Month for January, 2010 !


Lesson ID: 2009-00499